A US judge dismissed an investor suits against the web3 company Yuga Labs, who decided that the case failed to show off the bad tokens (NFT) that meet the legal sense of security.
Judge Fernando M. Olguin ruled out The plaintiffs did not show how the Ape Yacht Club (Bayc), Apecoin (Ape) or other NFT for sale by Yuga has satisfied three conditions of Howey Test, a standard used by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) to determine if a transaction qualifies as an investment contract. The lawsuit is Originally filed in 2022.
Yuba Labs sold its NFT as digital collectibles with membership perks at an exclusive club, making them consumable rather than investment contracts, Olguin said. He wrote:
“The fact that the defendants have promised that NFTs will provide the future, compared to the immediate, consumptive benefits are not alone sending benefits from consumptive to such investment in nature.”
The judge also said the plaintiffs failed to show that the bored yacht club and other NFT collections launched by Yuga was a “common business” with hopes of income made by others, increasing the legal preceding That most digital assets are not security.
Related: Nfts ‘heating up’ as nightclubs, rappers jump back to bandwagon
There is no common business with explicit revenue hoping
NFTs, who traded in public blockchain networks, did not establish an ongoing and dependent financial link between lab and yuga labs, and did not qualify as a “common business” underneath The test of HoweySaid Olguin.
Investors who bought NFT from the company paid Yuga fee independent NFT prices, Consensys attorney Bill Hughes write In X.
Finally, Olguin determined that the Yuga Labs did not make explicit revenue promises to prospective NFT buyers and that the roadmap for the project did not satisfy the conditions under the Howey’s test of revenue.
“Statements about the natural or intrinsic value of a product are not necessarily statements about income,” Olguin said.
“Statements about NFT prices and trading quantities are a bit closer to call, but even then, these statements themselves have failed to establish a revenue hope,” he added.
Magazine: Gordon Goner in his dramatic health battles and bored the apes who have been lying
